Do you think Bestseller lists have lost value?

Do you know what it means to be a bestselling author?

Well, for one thing, it may no longer mean a lot of books were sold. Think about that for a minute.

These questions, plus a few more, bounced around in my mind after reading a blog post on the Texas Authors website. (If you live in Texas be sure and check out this great organization.) Now back to the blog post that caught my attention.

Does Anybody Know What a Bestseller Is? By John Maher, with reporting by Rachel Deahl and Claire Kirch | Nov 03, 2017

The post pointed out something I’m sure most of us have noticed or read about, an overabundance of categories and subcategories on Amazon. You name it and the giant e-tailer most probably has a subcategory for the subject. Under Art & Photography, I counted 17 subcategories, one named Vehicle Pictorials. 

Before the gold rush of ebooks, there were two main categories for bestselling books—fiction and non-fiction. These two categories were broken down further into three major print formats—hardcover, trade paperback, and mass market paperback. The simplicity of this system made for easy tracking of bestselling books.

But then came ebooks, a new fourth category, and sold online. Online sales aren’t monitored or cataloged by brick-n-mortar stores, therefore, sales are not tracked in the same manner as print books.


While Amazon reports print sales, provided by Nielsen BookScan, it does not, for the most part, disclose sales of e-books. This sales number also does not include, sales to libraries, purchases by wholesalers such as Ingram, sales of used books, fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) sales or pre-orders—orders for a book before the book is released.


So who provides the most reliable guide for a bestseller list?

From John Maher’s article, I learned…

  • The two most transparent and reliable tracking organizations are:
    • NPD BookScan’s  and PW (Publishers Weekly) point-of-sale data, tracks 80%–85% of print sales in the country, but there again doesn’t (or can’t) track ebooks. Which, although good, provides an incomplete overall view.
  • Due to the number of lists, and Amazon’s decision not to share its e-book sales figures, it’s next to impossible identify what the top-selling books are across all formats in a particular week.
  • Which Bestseller lists carry weight with bookstores and readers?
  • I know it would stoke my ego, but having a book dubbed a “Bestseller” may not always translate into sales. Not like in the past. But what does translate into sales are:
    • Good reviews, coverage in high-profile media, and word-of-mouth.

Okay! I’ve got a few questions for you…

Do you think the term “Bestseller” or Bestselling Author” has become watered down by Amazon?

Do you believe it helps book sales? Print or ebook?

Did you know Amazon doesn’t report ebook sales?

Have you been disappointed after buying a book listed as a “Bestselling Novel?” (I have.)

Want to read more on the subject? Click on these posts!

Behind the Scam: What Does It Take to Be a ‘Best-Selling Author’? $3 and 5 Minutes.  By 

How Many Books Do You Need To Sell To Become A Bestseller?




6 thoughts on “Do you think Bestseller lists have lost value?

  1. I do think the list has lost some of its meaning. I used to be more likely to buy a book if it was on the list but anymore, I go by the title and the blurb on the back. In the case of ebooks, I go by the blurb given by Amazon.

    Your questions:
    Do you think the term “Bestseller” or Bestselling Author” has become watered down by Amazon?
    Not really. I do think the people who back the decision for these books aren’t as good at their job as they used to be.
    Do you believe it helps book sales? Print or ebook?
    Yes, there are a lot of people who cannot make the decision to buy a book completely by themselves. Someone else needs to tell them the book is worth buying.
    Did you know Amazon doesn’t report ebook sales?
    No, I did not know that. Should we get a petition going?
    Have you been disappointed after buying a book listed as a “Bestselling Novel?”
    Yes, there was one of Dan Brown’s books and a few of Andrew Greeley’s books.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Love your comment! I think Amazon’s algorithm is sometimes misleading. Now a petition might be a good idea. LOL I’ve been disappointed by Dan Brown too. Thanks for taking the time to leave such a great comment. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I think most of us like to read books written by authors who we’ve heard about from friends and relatives. I can’t tell if the, “Bestseller lists have lost value.” However some companies try to make us believe that the authors they recommend are the best.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.